Good afternoon,
just some more considerations:
while the lenghten of a trim-tab-operated steering rudder - disregarding if main- oder auxiliary rudder - is just as long as the trim-tab-axis is being situated behind the main - or auxiliary rudder shaft - so about max 50cm, the lenghten of the power lever on a pendulum rudder is being substancially longer, roughly between 130 - 190 cm. Thus the power output is huge compared with the - excuse me: a bit outdated trim-tab systems. Which is why so many of the previous manufacturers have ceised production since decades. Scanmar marine certainly is the last soldier to offer them.
Trim-Tab units have been one step amongst many steps in developments of windsteering systems during now about 50 years. In particular on long keeled boats this kind of gear have been popular and useful, while the todays boats designs certainly will not be the very best friends of these units with some particulars in terms of prevention of oversteering.
Importantly: yachtsmen being capable to make their boats obbey even under motor in reverse - might soon realize that a trim-tab, that cannot get centred and locked during maneouver under engine backwards - will at least causing some additional grey hair on skipper head - because the boat will not always do want what the skipper want it to do.
Life is a compromise - yachtsmen should at least know which one they will be accepting....
kind regards
Peter Foerthmann
http://www.windpilot.com